From Superman’s sweetheart to Hope McCrea’s sharp tongue, O’Toole’s legacy is one of strength, grace, and creative reinvention
Annette O’Toole’s name may now be synonymous with Virgin River‘s no-nonsense town mayor Hope McCrea, but her journey through Hollywood has been nothing short of legendary. With a career spanning over five decades, the Texas-born actress, singer, and songwriter has been a quiet powerhouse—on both screen and stage.
A Lifelong Performer Born to Dance
Born April 1, 1952, in Houston, Texas, Annette O’Toole (née Toole) was practically raised for the spotlight. Her mother was a dance teacher, and O’Toole started lessons at just three years old. By the time she turned 13, her family had moved to Los Angeles, where she began acting—a decision that would define the rest of her life.
Rising Through Hollywood: From Smile to Superman III
O’Toole’s early acting credits read like a crash course in classic TV: My Three Sons, The Virginian, Hawaii Five-O, and Gunsmoke. But her real breakthrough came in the 1975 satire Smile, quickly followed by starring roles in One on One and Foolin’ Around.
Her most iconic early role came in 1983 as Lana Lang, Clark Kent’s childhood love in Superman III. It was a performance that solidified her as part of superhero cinema history and showcased her girl-next-door charm on a blockbuster scale.
A Queen of TV Mini-Series
Throughout the ’80s and ’90s, O’Toole reigned over the TV mini-series landscape. She was unforgettable as adult Beverly Marsh in the 1990 adaptation of Stephen King’s It and earned an Emmy nomination for her portrayal of Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy in The Kennedys of Massachusetts.
From playing country legend Tammy Wynette in Stand by Your Man to starring in crime dramas like Dead by Sunset, she became known for her emotional range and fierce dedication to every role.
Martha Kent, Smallville, and the Superhero Return
In a poetic twist, 18 years after playing Lana Lang, O’Toole re-entered the Superman universe as Martha Kent—Clark’s adoptive mother—on the hit series Smallville. Her nurturing yet steel-strong portrayal lasted through six seasons and became one of the show’s emotional anchors.
The Virgin River Renaissance: Hope McCrea
Since 2019, O’Toole has stolen scenes in Netflix’s Virgin River as Hope McCrea, the town’s sharp-tongued, big-hearted mayor. A widow with opinions and zero patience for nonsense, Hope has become a fan-favorite thanks to O’Toole’s pitch-perfect delivery and undeniable screen presence.
Even when sidelined due to the pandemic in Season 3, her off-screen voiceovers kept her spirit in town. By Season 6, she’s front and center again—still running things her way.
A Songwriter with an Oscar Nod
O’Toole isn’t just an actress—she’s a gifted singer and songwriter. Alongside her husband, actor and musician Michael McKean, she co-wrote songs for the cult hit A Mighty Wind, including the Oscar-nominated ballad “A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow.”
The couple’s musical collaboration extends to concerts, Disney albums, and even touring with the iconic Spinal Tap in their Unwigged and Unplugged shows.
Did You Know?
-
She dated actor Bruno Kirby in the ‘70s and was married to actor Bill Geisslinger, with whom she has two daughters.
-
She married Michael McKean in 1999, whom she met filming Final Justice.
-
Her stage credits are extensive, with acclaimed Off-Broadway roles in Southern Comfort, Man from Nebraska, and The Traveling Lady.
-
She voiced Atlanna, Aquaman’s mother, in the unaired pilot for Aquaman (2006).
-
She once got a role (Smile, 1975) by pretending to be a dead cockroach at her audition—true story.
Awards and Nominations at a Glance
-
Academy Award nominee – Best Original Song (2004)
-
Primetime Emmy nominee – The Kennedys of Massachusetts (1990)
-
Golden Globe nominee – Best Actress in a Miniseries
-
Saturn Award nominee – Superman III
Legacy: Grace, Grit & Staying Power
Annette O’Toole is the kind of Hollywood legend who quietly reinvents herself with every decade—yet never strays from authenticity. Whether she’s wrangling a small town in Virgin River, grieving a superhero in Smallville, or singing about love’s strange harmonies, she brings both gravitas and warmth to everything she touches.
A timeless talent still at the top of her game, Annette O’Toole proves that true stars never fade—they just shine brighter with age.
