In CBS’ reimagining of the classic courtroom drama, Kathy Bates refuses to be a copy of Andy Griffith. Instead, she’s building something entirely new — and daringly personal.
When CBS announced it would reboot Matlock, many expected a nostalgic return to the genteel charm of the original 1980s series — a well-loved legal drama anchored by Andy Griffith’s warm, Southern persona. But then they cast Kathy Bates. And almost instantly, it became clear: this wasn’t going to be the same Matlock.
Bates, an Oscar and Emmy-winning powerhouse, is not one to follow a formula. “I didn’t watch the original,” she admitted in a candid interview. “Everyone always asked me that — did I study Griffith’s portrayal, or plan to mirror it? And the answer is no. I didn’t want that to influence me. I wanted to build Madeline from scratch.”
That bold declaration turned heads — and set the tone for a reboot unlike any CBS has attempted in years. Gone are the homey front porches and slow-talking witnesses. In their place: sharp suits, corporate corruption, and a lead character who speaks softly but carries a mind like a scalpel.
The New Matlock Isn’t a Man — And That Changes Everything
Madeline Matlock, the character Bates inhabits, is a retired judge who steps into the chaotic world of elite law firms to uncover deception from the inside out. She’s enigmatic, witty, and often underestimated by those around her — a dangerous mistake, as her adversaries soon discover.
“She walks into the room like someone’s grandmother,” said David Del Rio, who plays Billy, one of her closest confidants in the firm. “But by the time she walks out, she’s rearranged the chessboard.”
This version of Matlock isn’t interested in courtroom procedure as much as it is power dynamics. Madeline’s strength isn’t just her legal brilliance — it’s how she operates within systems designed to silence or sideline older women. At 76, Bates brings a world-weariness to the role that never dips into cynicism. Her Matlock doesn’t rage against ageism — she dismantles it, piece by piece.
Showrunner Jennie Snyder Urman, best known for Jane the Virgin, crafted the role with Bates in mind. “We knew we wanted Kathy,” Urman said. “And once we had her, we leaned into her strengths — the sharp intellect, the quiet menace, the humor that catches you off guard.”
Reimagining Without Erasing
The decision not to emulate Griffith’s Ben Matlock wasn’t just a creative choice — it was a statement. This reboot isn’t trying to overwrite the past; it’s trying to speak to the present. The legal landscape has changed. So has television. Bates’ Madeline lives in a world where justice is complicated, corporations manipulate the law, and truth isn’t always clean.
What Matlock does best is balance homage with disruption. The core premise — a clever outsider navigating legal systems — remains. But everything else has evolved. “The tone is more noir,” said Skye P. Marshall, who plays Olympia, a lawyer torn between ambition and conscience. “We’re less about weekly cases and more about unraveling big mysteries that thread through the season.”
Indeed, Matlock is serialized, cinematic, and morally messy — all elements rarely associated with CBS dramas. And yet, it’s working. Viewers are tuning in not out of nostalgia, but because this Matlock feels relevant.
An Unexpected Star Turn — at 76
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/matlock-kathy-bates-021925-8d4a073e826f484ab185919004fb1567.jpg)
At an age when most actresses are either sidelined or cast as comic relief, Bates is leading one of the network’s boldest shows. “I’m not here to play cute,” she said. “I’m here to play smart.”
The industry has taken notice. Early critical response to her performance has been glowing. Variety praised her for bringing “gravitas and unpredictability to a genre that often leans on tropes.” The Hollywood Reporter noted how Bates “commands every scene without raising her voice — a rare feat in a world of shouty procedurals.”
There’s something quietly revolutionary about her presence. In an age dominated by youth-driven content, Matlock dares to center an older woman — not as a sidekick or sage, but as a force of nature. Bates doesn’t need flash. Her greatest weapon is timing — the way she pauses just long enough to make you nervous.
The Future of Matlock: More Than a Reboot
Season one of the reboot wrapped with several unresolved threads: a hidden betrayal, a mysterious cover-up, and questions about Madeline’s own past. CBS has already greenlit a second season, and showrunner Urman promises even deeper twists.
“We’ve only just scratched the surface of who Madeline is,” Urman teased. “There’s history there — pain, secrets, choices she made that shaped the way she sees the law.”
For Bates, the journey is just beginning. “I never thought I’d be leading a network drama at this point in my life,” she said. “But I’m loving it. Because this isn’t about proving I still ‘have it.’ It’s about showing there’s no expiration date on complexity.”
Conclusion: A Legend Rewritten, Not Replaced
In reinventing Matlock, CBS hasn’t erased Andy Griffith’s legacy — it’s added to it. Kathy Bates’ take is bold, quiet, fierce, and completely her own. This is not the Matlock of the past. It’s a Matlock for now — and it works because it doesn’t try to fit in.
It dares to stand alone.
