Tracker’s success on CBS means it could get a spinoff — but which character in particular is in consideration to lead their own series? After the season 2 finale aired on Sunday, May 11, executive producer Elwood Reid exclusively told Us Weekly that expanding Tracker would be a dream, adding, “Come on, you got to tell CBS that.” The show’s creative team isn’t in a rush though — for a very specific reason. “There’s been a lot of shows that spin off incorrectly. The same level of care and craftsmanship that you see in Tracker has to be considered. My first rule of writing any show is, ‘Don’t do any harm to the main show. Don’t siphon something off,'” Reid, 58, hinted. “But at the same time, you have to make whatever you’re doing as good and as thoughtful.”
Everything to Know About ‘Tracker’ Season 3: From Possible Cast Changes to Returning Guest Stars. Reid acknowledged that Tracker’s record-breaking viewership makes the perfect case for creating more shows in the same universe. “Tracker is just one of those weird magic shows that came together. It resonated with people because there’s an emotional accessibility to that,” he continued. “You need that for any spinoff you do. You need someone who’s emotionally there and available. The stories can be surprising and fun.” Reid has spoken to star and fellow executive producer Justin Hartley about branching out, telling Us, “If the right idea comes by, we’ve had some loose ideas for spinoffs. If and when we are lucky enough to be able to do that, we have to do it in a way that is as good — if not better — than the original.”
Tracker, which premiered in February 2024, quickly found success after being coined the most-watched broadcast premiere since NCIS’ final episode with Mark Harmon in September 2021. Its average viewership was reported to be 18.2 million per episode, according to Paramount+ and broadcast measurements.
Variety’s annual list of the year’s 100 most-watched primetime telecasts revealed that Tracker episodes earned 15 top spots. Despite making Us wait 11 weeks for new episodes, the second season dominated viewership with the season 2 premiere bringing in 8.3 million total viewers — a nearly 10 percent increase in viewership from the season 1 finale. The season 2 premiere also marked the show’s highest audience since the series debuted in February 2024 after the Super Bowl.
If you’re obsessed with Tracker like most of us, you’ve probably noticed more than just the thrilling plots and tight suspense. The guest stars? Absolutely magnetic. And now, there’s serious buzz that Tracker might not stay a standalone story for long.
With fans begging for more, producers are reportedly considering spinoffs featuring standout guest characters. So the big question is — which guest star has what it takes to carry their own show?
Let’s dive into the possibilities, the fan theories, and the behind-the-scenes whispers fueling the Tracker spinoff buzz.
What Makes a Guest Star Spinoff-Worthy?
Charisma That Rivals the Lead
A successful spinoff needs a character who grabs attention the moment they walk on screen. We’re talking about screen presence that doesn’t fade next to Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw.
Strong Backstory With Loose Ends
Characters with deep, unresolved arcs leave room for storytelling. If a guest star walked away with secrets or hinted at a mysterious past — that’s gold for a potential series.
A World Beyond Tracker
Can the character exist in a world of their own? Some guest stars hinted at jobs, talents, or side plots that could easily evolve into a full-fledged series.
Top Guest Stars With Spinoff Potential
1. Reeva Patel — The Cyber Sleuth We Didn’t Know We Needed
Actress: Parminder Nagra
Episode: “The Ghost File”
Reeva brought brains, grit, and a personal vendetta that made her unforgettable. She wasn’t just assisting Colter — she was challenging him. With a dark past in cybersecurity and enemies still lurking in the shadows, Reeva’s story feels like it’s just getting started.
Why Reeva Could Lead Her Own Show
-
A unique angle: Cybercrime meets psychological thriller.
-
Strong female lead, tech-savvy but emotionally complex.
-
Think Mr. Robot meets Killing Eve.
2. Jesse Ortiz — The Bounty Hunter With a Moral Code
Actor: Diego Luna
Episode: “The Marked Path”
Jesse and Colter butted heads, but their chemistry was electric. He’s a bounty hunter who plays by his own rules, but unlike Colter, Jesse isn’t afraid to cross legal lines to get the job done.
What Makes Jesse Spinoff-Worthy
-
Gritty, high-octane missions in every episode.
-
The moral grey zone of bounty hunting explored.
-
Potential for dark humor and anti-hero vibes.
3. Dr. Eva Chen — The Rogue Psychologist Turned Profiler
Actress: Kelly Marie Tran
Episode: “Mind Over Tracker”
Eva’s story is dripping with tension. She lost her medical license after a patient went missing — now she works underground, helping law enforcement unofficially. Think she’s just helping? Think again.
What Her Spinoff Could Look Like
-
A thriller with deep dives into the criminal psyche.
-
Episodic profiling cases with an overarching mystery.
-
Emotional depth as she navigates her own trauma.
4. Malik Reyes — The Undercover Cop Caught Between Two Worlds
Actor: Manny Montana
Episode: “Deep Cover”
He walked a fine line between the law and crime families. His moral compass spins fast, but always points north in the end. His world? Dangerous. His story? Far from over.
This Is the Kind of TV Drama We Crave
-
Undercover work with real emotional stakes.
-
Can he stay alive while protecting the people he loves?
-
Perfect mix of action, drama, and identity crisis.
5. Sloan Morgan — The Ex-Cult Member Turned Investigator
Actress: Tatiana Maslany
Episode: “Sanctum Unraveled”
Tatiana’s guest role as Sloan had everyone talking. Raised in a cult, she escaped and now helps others do the same. Her knowledge of mind control tactics makes her a formidable investigator.
The Spinoff Potential Is Huge
-
Each episode could focus on a new cult.
-
Psychological drama meets real-life horror.
-
Emotional depth with themes of identity, loss, and redemption.
Why Spinoffs Actually Work (When Done Right)
Think ‘Better Call Saul’ or ‘The Mandalorian’
Not every show needs a spinoff, but when a character’s voice is strong enough, magic can happen. Better Call Saul was arguably as good — if not better — than Breaking Bad for some fans.
Tracker’s Guest Stars Are Already Fan Favorites
The audience already knows these characters. That’s half the battle won. All they need is a compelling plot and the right showrunner.
What a Tracker Expanded Universe Could Look Like
Themed Series Based on Expertise
-
Tech world (Reeva)
-
Psychological profiling (Eva)
-
Street justice (Jesse)
-
Cult investigations (Sloan)
Crossovers With Colter Shaw? Heck Yes
Imagine Colter appearing in a cameo episode to drop some wisdom — or stir the pot. That crossover potential alone is reason to build the universe.
The Fans Want More – Social Media Is Buzzing
Tweets, TikToks, and Fan Threads
Look up #TrackerSpinoff and you’ll find dozens of theories, fancasts, and wishlists. People aren’t just watching — they’re invested.
Fan Power Can Drive Network Decisions
Remember Lucifer getting saved by Netflix? Fans made that happen. If enough people demand a Tracker spinoff, it’s not a question of if — but when.
Which One Should Happen First? Our Final Take
If we had to bet money on one? Reeva Patel has all the makings of a breakout star. But honestly, all five could easily headline a show. Maybe the real answer is… why not all of them?
Conclusion: The Tracker Universe Is Just Warming Up
We’re at the beginning of what could become a massive TV universe. With strong guest stars, compelling backstories, and audience demand, Tracker has every reason to expand. Whether it’s Reeva cracking cyber cases or Jesse hunting fugitives, the future looks thrilling — and packed with possibility. So buckle up, Tracker fans. The ride might just be getting started.
