Another week and another new episode of Tracker is heading our way on May 4, 2025. Closer shares everything to know about the upcoming season 2, episode 19, which will hopefully lead Colter Shaw one step closer to finding out who killed his father.

Plot of Season 2, Episode 19, of ‘Tracker’ Is Revealed
Season 2, episode 19, of Tracker is called “Rules of the Game.” CBS released the synopsis of the upcoming episode a week ahead of its premiere. “When Reenie’s client, Leo Sharf (recurring guest star Pej Vahdat), hires Colter to track down his missing assistant before his company launch, the case takes a personal turn and Reenie becomes entangled in a deadly vendetta threatening both of their lives,” the logline of the episode said. Dory Shaw Will Be Making an Appearance in the Episode

In addition to seeing more of Pej Vahdat as Leo Sharf on Tracker, Dory Shaw, played by Melissa Roxburgh, will finally be making her return to the show as well. “Colter’s sister, Dory, delivers a mysterious piece of the Shaw family’s past,” executive producer Elwood Reid said of the appearance, per TV Insider. We’re pretty sure this is referencing the box of stuff that Dory has in her possession that once belonged to their dad. Colter was very interested to learn more about the contents inside after meeting with childhood pal Lizzy Hawking back in season 1. It’s a classic case of “What’s in the box?” and we are dying to know how it relates to Ashton’s death. It seems like the contents of the box could hold some more answers about Colter’s father’s job and what really got him in trouble. Viewers have only been given small clues so far about what happened to Ashton Shaw. It’s likely that he was murdered but there are no prime suspects from Colter’s perspective just yet, as his older brother, Russell Shaw, said that he didn’t kill Ashton.

We also don’t yet know why Dory kept the box a secret from her siblings. This implies that there is something incriminating in there that she doesn’t want them to see or further investigate. But, we’ll just have to wait and see how it all plays out in the rest of season 2. Melissa previously teased her return to the show, saying that it was a “short and sweet” appearance. However, she did not rule out appearing in season 3, which is set to premiere during the 2025-2026 broadcast season. “But hopefully there’s more for the next season because I know they got another season,” she teased. “It’s more just building the relationship and setting up for whatever comes next with the siblings.”

Welcome to One of the Wildest Episodes Yet

If you’ve been following Tracker, Season 2 Episode 19 just hit like a bolt of lightning. Dory Shaw is back. And no, it’s not just a quick cameo—her return flips everything upside down. Not only does she stir the emotional pot, but she drops hints that crack wide open the mystery around Ashton Shaw’s death.

So, what should you know? Grab your snack, sit back, and let’s break it down like a true fan detective.

Who Is Dory Shaw, and Why Does Her Return Matter?

Dory Shaw – Not Just a Side Character

Dory is more than just Colter’s sister. She’s a key emotional anchor in his life. Her disappearance (or, well, “absence”) left questions hanging in the air, and her reappearance reopens all of them.

Emotional Repercussions for Colter Shaw

When Dory walks back into Colter’s life, it’s not hugs and happy tears. It’s awkward tension, unresolved grief, and a heavy dose of suspicion. The emotional intensity? Palpable.

Ashton Shaw’s Death – Still a Giant Question Mark

Rewinding the Mystery

If you’ve forgotten, Ashton Shaw’s “death” has always felt fishy. No solid answers. Just whispers, fragments, and Colter’s obsession with finding out the truth.

Dory Drops a Bombshell

This episode gave us something new—Dory hints at things Colter didn’t know. Things Ashton might’ve been involved in. Something shady? You bet.

Clues That Can’t Be Ignored

The Letter in the Box

Yes, that letter. In Episode 19, Colter finds a letter stashed away in an old ammo box. It’s signed “A.S.” Could Ashton have faked his death?

The Map Fragment

That little scrap of a map Dory hands Colter? It matches one Ashton used in Season 1. Coincidence? Nah, we’re not buying that.

The Episode’s Themes – Trust, Betrayal, and Family

Can Colter Even Trust His Sister?

Dory’s return isn’t all smiles. She’s clearly hiding something. Maybe it’s guilt. Maybe it’s fear. Maybe it’s both.

Family Ties Are Complicated

Tracker isn’t just about solving mysteries—it’s about emotional truths. And this episode hammers that home.

Dory’s New Motives – What Is She Really After?

She’s Not Just Visiting

Let’s get real—Dory didn’t just pop in to say “hey.” Her arrival is too perfectly timed. There’s a reason, and it’s tied to Ashton.

H3: Something About That USB Drive…

Yep, she’s got one. It’s encrypted. And based on her reaction, it might be the key to unlocking Ashton’s secret life.

Symbolism and Foreshadowing in Episode 19

The Broken Watch

Colter finds Ashton’s old broken watch. Still ticking. A metaphor? Maybe Ashton’s story isn’t over.

H3: That Old Treehouse Scene

Remember the treehouse flashback? It’s not just filler. It reveals how Ashton and Dory once kept secrets together.

Fans Are Losing It – Reactions Are Off the Charts

Social media exploded after Episode 19 aired. The hashtags #DoryShawReturns and #AshtonMystery trended for hours. And Reddit theories? Wild. But fun.

Episode 19 Sets the Stage for a Game-Changing Finale

This isn’t just another episode. It’s the calm before the storm. The big reveal is coming, and if we read the signs right—Colter’s about to uncover more than he bargained for.

Let’s Talk Easter Eggs – Did You Catch These?

Newspaper Clipping in the Background

Zoom in, and you’ll see a headline from years ago. “Local Man Presumed Dead After Cabin Fire.” Ashton, anyone?

The Song Playing in the Background

“Ghosts That Haunt Me.” Subtle? Nope. It’s basically screaming Ashton is still alive.

Theories Flying Around the Fandom

Ashton’s in Hiding?

One theory says Ashton is deep undercover. Maybe he got too close to something dangerous.

Dory Knew All Along?

Another hot take: Dory knew Ashton was alive and helped fake his death. Gasp-worthy, but oddly plausible.

How Episode 19 Changes Colter’s Arc

Colter’s not just solving other people’s problems anymore. This mystery is his. And it’s about to define the rest of the season—and maybe the series.

What We Still Don’t Know

1. Is Ashton alive?

2. Why did Dory really return?

3. What’s on that USB drive?

4. Was Ashton working with someone dangerous?

5. And most importantly—what happens next?

Final Thoughts – Buckle Up, It’s Getting Wild

Tracker Season 2, Episode 19 did more than bring back a familiar face. It cracked the mystery wide open, shifted the emotional weight, and gave us more questions than answers. But that’s the beauty of it—it keeps us guessing, keeps us hooked, and keeps us hungry for more.

Conclusion

Episode 19 of Tracker Season 2 is a turning point. It’s emotional, mysterious, and packed with clues. Dory’s return doesn’t just shake Colter—it shakes the entire storyline. Ashton’s death? Maybe it’s a lie. Maybe it’s more complicated. One thing’s for sure: the truth is coming, and it’s going to hit hard.