Colter (Justin Hartley) does not like to mix business with pleasure, but sometimes, a tracker can only resist so much. The question about his dating status came up in Tracker Season 2, Episode 17, “Memories,” but Colter was careful to avoid speaking about it. And that’s because it’s complicated. The next case takes him to Michigan, where a young woman went missing. “Colter heads to Willow Creek, Michigan, after a worried mother hires him to track down her beauty queen daughter, Riley, who vanished while driving home from work. While investigating at the garden center where Riley works, Colter looks into her modeling past and uncovers that she was hiding a major secret,” reads the logline for Tracker Season 2, Episode 18, “Collision.”
CBS released a sneak peek of the episode airing on Sunday, April 27, previewing this case and a potential romance for Colter. The video below teases the case as Colter arrives in Michigan. It shows the circumstances under which Riley went missing after she was run off the road while driving home. This hints at a complicated disappearance, and Riley could be in serious danger. His investigation takes him to her place of work and also introduces him to a law enforcement officer from the local police department. While they search for Riley, sparks fly between them. “If you ever decide to teach a night class on how to become a human bloodhound, I’ll be the first to sign up,” she says. Is that Colter smiling ear to ear? It seems the easiest way to Colter’s heart is to compliment him. However, romance will have to take a backseat when things escalate, and they find themselves in a shootout.
If you thought Tracker was just about mystery, adrenaline, and solving crimes, think again. Season 2 is about to throw a curveball right into Colter Shaw’s emotionally guarded world—and fans are already losing it. A newly released sneak peek suggests that romance is on the horizon for our favorite lone wolf tracker. Let’s dive deep into what this means for the show, the character, and why this unexpected twist might just be what takes Tracker from gripping to downright unforgettable.
Colter Shaw isn’t your average hero. He’s a reward-seeking survivalist who travels across America solving mysteries, tracking people, and confronting danger wherever it lurks. Haunted by his family’s tragic past and driven by a personal moral code, Colter’s emotional isolation has always been part of his charm. But what happens when someone gets close enough to challenge that wall?
Romance Rumors Begin: What the Sneak Peek Shows
In the latest sneak peek for Tracker Season 2, viewers catch a brief yet charged moment between Colter and a new female character. There’s eye contact. There’s a pause. There’s subtle tension. It’s not much—but enough for diehard fans to immediately start speculating.
Why It Feels Different This Time
Colter has met interesting women before, but this connection feels deeper. Unlike previous flings or passing interactions, this feels like the show is laying the groundwork for something real. Maybe even…permanent?
A Strategic Move by the Writers?
Injecting Emotion Into a Thriller
Adding romance to a high-octane show like Tracker might sound risky, but it could be a genius move. It humanizes Colter, makes him more relatable, and opens doors for richer storytelling. Think about it: a man who spends his life finding others… might finally be found himself.
Who Is The Mystery Woman?
New Character, New Vibes
While the showrunners haven’t officially confirmed who she is, rumors suggest she may be a fellow tracker, journalist, or even someone tied to one of the rewards Colter’s chasing. Whoever she is, fans are dying to know.
Chemistry Check: Does It Work?
From the short clip alone, the chemistry is undeniable. There’s a balance of tension and intrigue—like they’re sizing each other up, but also drawn together.
What This Means for Season 2’s Storyline
More Than Just Romance
This potential relationship could become a key subplot. It may shape Colter’s decisions, test his loyalty, or even become a vulnerability enemies can exploit.
Emotional Depth Incoming
Prepare for more flashbacks, personal revelations, and emotional tension. This romance might force Colter to confront parts of himself he’s long buried.
Fan Reactions So Far
Social Media Is Exploding
The #TrackerSeason2 hashtag has been trending, and fan theories are flooding Twitter, Reddit, and TikTok. Some are thrilled, others worried it might “soften” Colter’s edge.
Everyone Has an Opinion
Love it or hate it, everyone’s talking about it—and that’s exactly what a show wants before a new season drops.
Could This Be Long-Term?
Is Colter Finally Ready for Love?
Maybe. Maybe not. But this arc seems like a turning point. If Colter allows someone in, it could completely redefine who he is—not just as a tracker, but as a man.
Will It Fit the Puzzle?
Romance in action-thrillers can sometimes feel forced. But if Tracker plays it right, this could be the emotional anchor the show never knew it needed.
Where Does This Lead Colter?
A Crossroads for Character Development
Colter’s relationship with this mystery woman might shape his values and strategies. Will he become more cautious? More open? Less of a lone wolf?
Will He Let Go of the Past?
So much of Colter’s journey has been about grappling with his traumatic upbringing. A real connection might help him heal—or rip the scabs wide open.
Conflict Is Inevitable
Love vs. The Mission
If Colter has to choose between saving someone and protecting his new partner, what will he do? We’re guessing Season 2 will throw him into some brutal moral dilemmas.
Behind-the-Scenes Teasers
Actors Drop Hints
In recent interviews, Justin Hartley (who plays Colter) hinted that this season explores “new emotional terrain.” Could that be code for love?
The Writers Are Stirring the Pot
Writers have teased a “deeper dive into Colter’s personal life,” confirming fans aren’t imagining things.
