This police officer is not Colter’s first love interest on the show, as he has been linked to Reenie (Fiona Rene) and Billie (Sofia Pernas). Colter also dated Gina Pickett’s sister before Gina disappeared. His past relationships are complicated. It was casual and sporadic with Reenie, but given her new love interest, she doesn’t seem keen on revisiting things with Colter. They have developed a friendship and are comfortable keeping it there. “They developed this really good trust between the two of them. I think there are very few people that Colter trusts, and she’s one of them. And you don’t see that a lot on TV where there’s just this platonic friendship that’s a really good friendship,” Harley told TV Insider of where Reenie and Colter stand. With Billie, it’s also complicated since they are rivals in their work, and they rarely see each other. Could this police officer be the one who sticks around?
Love is hard. But if you’re Colter Shaw, it’s practically impossible. In Tracker, Shaw isn’t just tracking criminals—he’s also dodging his own emotions like bullets. The man is a mystery, wrapped in leather, brooding under a five o’clock shadow. But what’s really going on behind those intense eyes? Let’s peel back the layers of Colter Shaw’s tangled love life and explore why romance is the one case he can’t seem to crack.
Who Is Colter Shaw?
Before we dive into his heart, let’s talk about the man. Colter Shaw is the lone-wolf survivalist with a knack for solving crimes and collecting reward money. He’s rugged, resourceful, and always on the move—part detective, part cowboy, part ghost.
The Lone Ranger With a Locked Heart
Why Love Doesn’t Come Easy for Shaw
Shaw is emotionally guarded. He grew up in a chaotic family situation that taught him one thing: don’t get too close. And that lesson stuck. Every time someone gets too near, Shaw hits the road again.
The “Attachment Problem”
It’s not just being busy—Colter has an actual fear of attachment. He connects, then disconnects. His emotional compass is skewed by a past that never gave him room to feel safe.
Past Lovers: A Trail of Broken Hearts
The Ones Who Got Away
Throughout the series, we get glimpses of past relationships—women who wanted more than he could give. These connections are deep, but temporary. Each woman reflects a different part of Colter’s fractured identity.
The One Who Changed Everything
There’s always that one. For Colter, she wasn’t just another romantic interest—she was a mirror to his soul. But like most things in his life, timing and trauma got in the way.
Shaw’s Communication Style: Stoic & Subtle
He Talks in Actions, Not Words
Let’s be real—Colter Shaw doesn’t do long heart-to-hearts. His idea of affection? Saving your life, giving you a look, and disappearing by morning.
Why This Pushes Partners Away
Most people need more than glances and gestures. They want emotional presence—and Shaw often fails to show up where it matters most.
The Psychology Behind Colter Shaw’s Avoidance
Childhood Trauma & Emotional Survival
Raised by a paranoid father and left to fend for himself, Shaw learned to rely only on… well, Shaw. Trusting others became a luxury he couldn’t afford.
Emotional Armor: His Invisible Shield
Love means vulnerability. Vulnerability means danger. That’s how his mind works. Shaw’s entire identity is wrapped in self-protection.
Love on the Move: Can Relationships Survive His Lifestyle?
The Constant Traveling
How do you build a life with someone when you’re always chasing danger in a different state every week?
Commitment in a Crisis
Even when romance blossoms, it’s always tested by chaos—gunshots, getaways, moral gray areas. Not exactly the stuff of candlelit dinners.
When Love Interferes With The Mission
Romantic Distractions or Emotional Anchors?
Colter often sees relationships as liabilities. But deep down, he craves connection. He’s just terrified it’ll slow him down or cloud his judgment.
He Runs Toward Danger, Away From Love
It’s ironic. He’ll run into gunfire for strangers but won’t run into the arms of someone who loves him. It’s not bravery—it’s fear.
The Puzzle of Colter Shaw’s Emotional Intelligence
Street Smart but Emotionally Clueless
The man can track a criminal through the wilderness without a compass. But when it comes to feelings? Total rookie.
His Inner Conflict
He wants intimacy, but he doesn’t know what to do with it. Every time someone shows him love, he freezes.
Is There Hope for Love?
Character Development on the Horizon
The show hints at growth. We see cracks in the armor. Maybe, just maybe, he’ll start letting people in.
A Love That Lasts?
Fans are rooting for a real, grounded romance—someone who matches his strength but challenges his emotional walls.
What Kind of Partner Does Colter Shaw Need?
Strong, Independent, and Emotionally Savvy
He needs someone who doesn’t need saving, someone who understands space but offers stability. A calm in his storm.
Not a Damsel, But a Mirror
The perfect match isn’t someone who tames him—but someone who gets him and makes him want to stay.
What We Can Learn From Shaw’s Love Life
We All Have Emotional Armor
Maybe we’re not all bounty hunters, but we’ve all been hurt. We all build walls. Shaw’s journey shows the cost of keeping them up too long.
Love Takes Work, Even for Badasses
No matter how tough you are, love takes effort, vulnerability, and sometimes, therapy.
How the Show Handles Romance
Subtle, Not Soap Opera
Tracker doesn’t throw romance in your face. It lets it simmer, making it all the more real. You feel the tension, the hesitation—the raw humanity.
Fan Reactions
Viewers feel Shaw’s emotional distance. They yell at their screens. They write fanfics. The guy’s got a hold on people’s hearts—and maybe, eventually, he’ll open his own.
Conclusion: Colter Shaw’s Greatest Mystery Is Himself
For all the crimes he’s solved and people he’s saved, the biggest enigma Colter Shaw faces is his own heart. His love life isn’t just complicated—it’s a battlefield of scars, hope, and silent longing. But we’re rooting for him. Because if a guy like Shaw can figure out love, maybe there’s hope for the rest of us too.
