Introduction: Who Was Vivian Vance?
When you think of I Love Lucy, you probably picture Lucy Ricardo’s hilarious sidekick, Ethel Mertz, portrayed by the legendary Vivian Vance. But as with any celebrity, myths and misconceptions about Vance have circulated for decades. Was she really feuding with Lucille Ball? Did she despise her on-screen husband, Fred Mertz? Let’s dive in and uncover the truth behind eight of the most persistent myths about Vivian Vance.
1. Vivian Vance Hated Playing Ethel Mertz
Many fans believe Vivian Vance loathed her role as Ethel Mertz. After all, Ethel was often dressed in frumpy outfits and was portrayed as less glamorous than Lucy. However, this couldn’t be further from the truth.
While Vance was initially concerned about the dowdy appearance of Ethel, she quickly embraced the character, recognizing how much audiences adored her. In fact, Ethel’s relatability was a major reason for the show’s success, and Vance was proud to contribute to its legacy.
2. She Had a Bitter Feud with Lucille Ball
It’s a common myth that Vivian Vance and Lucille Ball were constantly at odds behind the scenes. However, the reality was quite the opposite.
Vance and Ball developed a deep friendship during their years on I Love Lucy. Sure, they had occasional disagreements—what coworkers don’t?—but their bond was undeniable. After the show ended, they remained close friends, with Vance even guest-starring on Ball’s later TV ventures.
3. Vivian Vance and William Frawley Couldn’t Stand Each Other
The on-screen chemistry between Ethel and Fred Mertz (played by William Frawley) was comedic gold, but rumors of off-screen animosity have overshadowed their performances.
It’s true that Vance and Frawley weren’t the best of friends—they had different personalities and a significant age gap that sometimes led to clashes. However, their professional relationship was largely civil, and both respected each other’s talent. The myth of outright hatred has been greatly exaggerated.
4. She Was Fired from I Love Lucy
Contrary to popular belief, Vivian Vance was not fired from I Love Lucy. She chose to leave the show’s follow-up series, The Lucy-Desi Comedy Hour, because she wanted to explore other opportunities and spend more time with her family.
Her departure wasn’t due to conflict or dissatisfaction but was simply a career decision. Fans often mistake her leaving as a forced exit, but Vance was in control of her choices.
5. Vivian Vance Wasn’t a Talented Actress
Some skeptics claim that Vivian Vance’s success was solely due to Lucille Ball’s star power. This myth couldn’t be further from the truth.
Vance was a seasoned stage actress before joining I Love Lucy, with a Broadway career that showcased her comedic timing and dramatic chops. Her ability to hold her own alongside Ball, one of television’s biggest stars, speaks volumes about her talent.
6. She Was Never Married
A surprising number of fans believe Vivian Vance was never married, perhaps due to her iconic portrayal of the fictional Mrs. Ethel Mertz.
In reality, Vance was married four times throughout her life. While her personal relationships had their ups and downs, this myth likely persists because her private life was overshadowed by her on-screen persona.
7. She Retired Because of Health Issues
Another misconception is that Vivian Vance retired early due to declining health. While she did face health challenges later in life, including a battle with cancer, her decision to slow down was more about prioritizing her happiness and enjoying her personal life.
Vance continued to act in guest roles and even reunited with Lucille Ball on several occasions, showing her enduring passion for performing.
8. Vivian Vance and Fred Mertz Were a Real-Life Couple
This myth likely stems from the convincing chemistry between Ethel and Fred Mertz. While their bickering and banter felt authentic, Vance and Frawley were not a couple in real life.
In fact, their age difference and differing lifestyles made the idea of a romantic relationship laughable. They were simply co-stars who brought their characters to life with undeniable skill.
The Legacy of Vivian Vance
Vivian Vance’s contribution to I Love Lucy and television history is undeniable. Despite the myths and misconceptions, her talent, charm, and humor made her a beloved icon. Whether she was delivering a witty comeback or sharing a heartfelt moment with Lucy, Vance left an indelible mark on the hearts of fans.
So, the next time you hear a rumor about Vivian Vance, remember: the truth is often far more fascinating than fiction.
Conclusion
Vivian Vance was more than Ethel Mertz—she was a trailblazing actress, a supportive friend, and an enduring figure in entertainment. By debunking these myths, we can appreciate her legacy for what it truly is: a testament to talent, resilience, and the magic of television.
FAQs
1. Was Vivian Vance friends with Lucille Ball in real life?
Yes, Vance and Ball had a close friendship that lasted long after I Love Lucy ended.
2. Why did Vivian Vance leave The Lucy-Desi Comedy Hour?
She wanted to pursue other opportunities and spend more time with her family.
3. Did Vivian Vance and William Frawley really hate each other?
While they weren’t close friends, their professional relationship was mostly respectful.
4. What other shows did Vivian Vance appear in?
Vance guest-starred in several of Lucille Ball’s later shows, including The Lucy Show and Here’s Lucy.
5. Did Vivian Vance win any awards for her role as Ethel Mertz?
Yes, she won the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actress in 1954, a testament to her incredible talent.
